Research progress on emergency-synergy in public health emergencies over past decade

doi:10.16265/j.cnki.issn1003-3033.2025.11.1675

Abstract

Abstract:

In order to capture the evolving landscape of research on emergency-synergy in public health emergencies and systematically synthesize key studies and their characteristics in this domain, this study employed the scientific knowledge mapping tool CiteSpace to conduct a visual analysis of relevant literature from the past decade. Data were retrieved from core collections of China National Knowledge Infrastructure(CNKI)and Web of Science(WOS). Concurrently, existing research findings were systematically examined across five dimensions: synergistic models, mechanisms, subjects, decision-making processes, and model construction. The results indicate that research output on emergency-synergy in public health emergencies grew steadily alongside the progression of Corona Virus Disease 2019(COVID-19) pandemic, with a subsequent decline as the pandemic subsided. Overall publication volume in this field remains modest: the retrieval yielded 121 academic papers, 306 master's and doctoral theses, and 54 foreign-language documents. Research focus is predominantly concentrated in areas such as emergency management, collaboration mechanisms, and multi-stakeholder synergy. The analysis further reveals that evolutionary game theory and dynamic disease transmission theory have gained significant traction among researchers in modeling emergency-synergy. The synergistic mechanism featuring "government leadership, multi-party participation, and clear division of responsibilities" has garnered widespread recognition within the academic community. Nevertheless, challenges persist regarding the practical implementation of multi-subject emergency synergy under government leadership, warranting further in-depth investigation. It is projected that future research will advance toward theoretical refinement of emergency-synergy governance models and the diversification of synergistic subjects.

Key words: sudden public health crisis, emergency-synergy, CiteSpace, emergency management, synergistic mechanism, multi-party

CLC Number:

YANG Yi, ZHENG Ran, LIU Yue, LUO Yongjun, LYU Nan, YU Xuan. Research progress on emergency-synergy in public health emergencies over past decade[J]. China Safety Science Journal, 2025, 35(11): 253-262.

Figures/Tables 7

Fig.1

Fig.2

Fig.3

Fig.4

Fig.5

Fig.6

Table 1

Main literatures on public health emergency-synergy in the world

序号	题目	期刊		被引频次
1	Understanding public transport satisfaction in post COVID-19 pandemic	Transport Policy		121
2	Assessing the South Korean model of emergency management during the COVID-19 Pandemic	Asian Studies Review		42
3	News sections, journalists and information sources in the journalistic coverage of crises and emergencies in Spain	Profesional De La Informacion		35
4	The flint water crisis, the karegnondi water authority and strategic-structural racism	Critical Sociology		32
5	Government information disclosure and citizen coproduction during COVID-19 in China	Governance-an International Journal of Policy Administration and Institutions		28
6	A comparison of China's risk communication in response to SARS and H7N9 using principles drawn from international practice	Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness		20
7	Unveiling the role of knowledge management capabilities in strategic emergency response: insights from the impact of COVID-19 on China's new economy firms	Journal of Knowledge Management		19
8	Whole community co-production: a full picture behind the successful COVID-19 response in S. Korea	Transforming Government People Process & Policy		15
9	Children facing natural, economic and public health crisis in Europe: the risks of a predictable unpredictability	Turk Pediatri Arsivi-Turkish Archives of Pediatrics		13
10	Improvement of emergency management mechanism of public health crisis in rural China: a review article	Iranian Journal of Public Health		13
11	New media platform's understanding of Chinese social workers' anti-epidemic actions: an analysis of network public opinion based on COVID-19	Social Work in Public Health		12
12	Interactive governance between and within governmental levels and functions: a social network analysis of China's case against COVID-19	American Review of Public Administration		11
13	Quantifying the influence of delay in opinion transmission of COVID-19 information propagation: modeling study		Journal of Medical Internet Research	9
14	城市突发公共卫生事件应急管理研究		江西师范大学硕士学位论文	0
15	多元主体参与社区疫情防控问题研究		中南财经政法大学硕士学位论文	2
16	共享文档:突发公共卫生事件网络救助与社会响应的新渠道		华东师范大学硕士学位论文	1
17	京津冀应急物流协同度评价及影响因素研究		天津理工大学硕士学位论文	2
18	浅谈公共卫生与疾病预防控制体系建设		中国科学院院刊	73
19	社会组织参与应急管理的危机学习-协同治理机制研究		河海大学学报:哲学社会科学版	35
20	突发公共卫生事件的政府响应效能诊断PSR模型的应用		重庆社会科学	40
21	突发公共卫生事件信息协同研究现状与展望		现代情报	20
22	突发公共卫生事件应对中的地方政府行为优化研究		山东农业大学硕士学位论文	8
23	突发公共卫生事件中的政社协同困境及治理路径优化研究		山东大学硕士学位论文	11
24	县级政府突发公共卫生事件应急机制优化研究		广西民族大学硕士学位论文	0
25	协同优势视角下突发公共卫生事件社区网格化治理研究		中国卫生政策研究	53

Table 1

References 48

[1]	王小理. 生物安全时代:新生物科技变革与国家安全治理[J]. 国际安全研究, 2020, 38(4):109-135,159-160.
	WANG Xiaoli. The age of biosecurity: new biotechnology revolution and national biosecurity governance[J]. Journal of International Security Studies, 2020, 38(4): 109-135, 159-160.
[2]	司林波, 裴索亚. 国家生物安全风险防控和治理的影响因素与政策启示:基于扎根理论的政策文本研究[J]. 中共天津市委党校学报, 2021, 23(3):61-71.
	SI Linbo, PEI Suoya. The influencing factors and policy enlightenment of national biosecurity risk control and governance:research on policy text based on grounded theory[J]. Journal of the Party School of Tianjin Committee of the CPC, 2021, 23(3): 61-71.
[3]	章楚加. 生物安全风险协同共治范式的建构逻辑与规范内涵:基于《生物安全法》评述视角[J]. 青海社会科学, 2021(5):154-161.
	ZHANG Chujia. Construction logic and normative connotation of collaborative governance paradigm for biosecurity risks:a review perspective based on the biosecurity law[J]. Qinghai Social Sciences, 2021(5): 154-161.
[4]	赫尔曼·哈肯[德]. 协同学-大自然构成的奥秘[M]. 凌复华,译. 上海: 上海译文出版社, 2005:15-75.
	HAKEN H. Synergetics: the secret of nature's structure[M]. LING Fuhua,Translated. Shanghai: Shanghai Translation Publishing House, 2005:15-75.
[5]	SCHNEIDER S K. Governmental response to disasters:the conflict between bureaucratic procedures and emergent norms[J]. Public Administration Review, 1992, 52(2):135-145. doi: 10.2307/976467
[6]	郭景涛. 城市群重大公共安全事件应急指挥协同研究[D]. 武汉: 华中科技大学, 2016.
	GUO Jingtao. The optimization study on cooperative relationship of emergency command for major emergency of urban agglomeration safety incidents in urban agglomerations[D]. Wuhan: Huazhong University of Science and Technology, 2016.
[7]	刘楠, 侯林. 协同视角下地方政府应对突发公共卫生事件治理研究[J]. 国际公关, 2024(2):101-103.
	LIU Nan, HOU Lin. Governance of local governments in responding to public health emergencies from a collaborative perspective[J]. International Public Relations, 2024(2): 101-103.
[8]	李维安, 孟乾坤, 刘昱沛, 等. 公共卫生危机应急协同治理:基于火神山医院和红十字会的案例分析[J]. 工程管理科技前沿, 2024, 43(3):8-17.
	LI Weian, MENG Qiankun, LIU Yupei, et al. Emergency collaborative governance of public health crisis:a case study of Huoshenshan hospital and the Red Cross[J]. Frontiers of Science and Technology of Engineering Management, 2024, 43(3): 8-17.
[9]	THOMPSON D, MCCUAIG J, WILKES B. 跨部门合作原则及特点[C]. 环境治理跨部门合作研讨会论文集, 2007:17-24.
	THOMPSON D, MCCUAIG J, WILKES B. Principles and characteristics of cross-sectoral collaboration[C]. Proceedings of the Symposium on Cross-sectoral Collaboration in Environmental Governance, 2007:17-24.
[10]	EISINGER P. Imperfect federalism: the intergovernmental partnership for homeland security[J]. Public Administration Review, 2010, 66(4):537-545. doi: 10.1111/puar.2006.66.issue-4
[11]	李安楠, 邓修权, 赵秋红. 分形视角下的非常规突发事件应急组织动态重构:以8·12天津港爆炸事件为例[J]. 管理评论, 2016, 28(8):193-206.
	LI Annan, DENG Xiuquan, ZHAO Qiuhong. Unconventional emergency organizational dynamic reconstruction based on fractal:8.12 Tianjin explosions case study[J]. Management Review, 2016, 28(8): 193-206.
[12]	KOLIBA C J, MILLS R M, ZIA A. Accountability in governance networks: an assessment of public, private, and nonprofit emergency management practices following hurricane katrina[J]. Public Administration Review, 2011, 71(2):210-220. doi: 10.1111/puar.2011.71.issue-2
[13]	柯小玲, 刘正娟, 郭海湘, 等. 基于三方演化博弈的突发公共卫生事件应急响应及仿真研究[J]. 运筹学报, 2024, 28(1):57-76.
	KE Xiaoling, LIU Zhengjuan, GUO Haixiang, et al. Emergency response and simulation research for public health emergencies based on tripartite evolutionary game[J]. Journal of Operations Research Society of China, 2024, 28(1): 57-76.
[14]	薛澜, 彭宗超, 钟开斌, 等. 中国公共卫生应急指挥体系探析[J]. 中国工程科学, 2021, 23(5):1-8. doi: 10.15302/J-SSCAE-2021.05.001
	XUE Lan, PENG Zongchao, ZHONG Kaibin, et al. Public health emergency command system of china[J]. Strategic Study of Chinese Academy of Engineering, 2021, 23(5): 1-8.
[15]	张海波, 童星. 中国应急管理效能的生成机制[J]. 中国社会科学, 2022(4):64-82,205-206.
	ZHANG Haibo, TONG Xing. The generative mechanisms for the effectiveness of emergency management in China[J]. Social Sciences in China, 2022(4): 64-82,205-206.
[16]	WAUGH W L, STREIB G. Collaboration and leadership for effective emergency management[J]. Public Administration Review, 2006, 66(S1):131-140. doi: 10.1111/puar.2006.66.issue-s1
[17]	KAPUCU N, HU Q. Understanding multiplexity of collaborative emergency management networks[J]. American Review of Public Administration, 2016, 46(4):399-417. doi: 10.1177/0275074014555645
[18]	KAPUCU N, GARAYEV V. Designing,manging, and sustaining functionally collaborative emergency management networks[J]. American Review of Public Administration, 2013, 43(3):312-330. doi: 10.1177/0275074012444719
[19]	NOHRSTEDT D. Expaining mobilization and performance of collaborations in routine emergency management[J]. Administration & Society, 2016, 48(2):135-162.
[20]	CIGLER B A. Hurricane Katrina: two intergovernmental challenges[J]. The Public Manager, 2007, 35(4):3-7.
[21]	CAIN E B, GERBER R E, HUI I. The challenge of externally generated collaborative governance: california's attempt at regional water management[J]. The American Review of Public Administration, 2020, 50(4/5):428-437. doi: 10.1177/0275074020908578
[22]	杨舒雨, 谭爽. 突发公共卫生事件沟通困境与破解之道:博弈理论视角[J]. 青岛医药卫生, 2024, 56(2):141-144.
	YANG Shuyu, TAN Shuang. Communication dilemma of public health emergencies and the way to crack it-game theory perspective[J]. Qingdao Medical Journal, 2024, 56(2): 141-144.
[23]	NOHRSTEDT D. Does adaptive capacity influence service delivery? evidence from swedish emergency management collaborations[J]. Public Management Review, 2015, 17(5):718-735. doi: 10.1080/14719037.2013.848921
[24]	LUBELL M, MEWHIRTER M J, BERARDO R, et al. Transaction costs and the perceived effectiveness of complex institutional systems[J]. Public Administration Review, 2017, 77(5):668-680. doi: 10.1111/puar.2017.77.issue-5
[25]	仝鹏. 健全地方政府应急管理的协同体系机制研究[J]. 中国管理信息化, 2016, 19(22):176-177.
	TONG Peng. Research on improving collaborative system mechanism of local government emergency management[J]. China Management Informationization, 2016, 19(22): 176-177.
[26]	KAPUCU N, AUGUSTIN M E, GARAYEV V. Interstate partnerships in emergency management: emergency management assistance compact in response to catastrophic disasters[J]. Public Administration Review, 2009, 69(2):297-313. doi: 10.1111/puar.2009.69.issue-2
[27]	SORENSEN E, TORFING J. Enhancing collaborative innovation in the public sector[J]. Administration & Society, 2011, 43(8):842-868.
[28]	赵林度, 杨世才. 基于Multi_Agent的城际灾害应急管理信息和资源协同机制研究[J]. 灾害学, 2009, 24(1):139-143.
	ZHAO Lindu, YANG Shicai. Information and resources synergetic mechanism of inter-city disaster emergency management based on multi-agent systems[J]. Journal of Catastrophology, 2009, 24(1): 139-143.
[29]	刘洪渭, 张朋柱, 李树荣, 等. 突发公共事件的决策网络及其协同决策分类[J]. 上海管理科学, 2011, 33(1):89-93.
	LIU Hongwei, ZHANG Pengzhu, LI Shurong, et al. Research on decision network and coordination decision classification[J]. Shanghai Management Science, 2011, 33(1): 89-93.
[30]	关雷, 佟士祺, 颜华琨, 等. 基于群体网络计划的应急协同决策方法[J]. 大连海事大学学报, 2012, 38(3):73-76.
	GUAN Lei, TONG Shiqi, YAN Huakun, et al. Emergency collaborative decision-making method based on group network planning[J]. Journal of Dalian Maritime University, 2012, 38(3): 73-76.
[31]	宋艳, 王博石. 我国地震灾害应急协同决策系统可靠性建模与仿真[J]. 自然灾害学报, 2014, 23(3):171-180.
	SONG Yan, WANG Boshi. Modeling and simulaton of reliability of earthquake disaster emergency coordination decision-making system in China[J]. Journal of Natural Disasters, 2014, 23(3): 171-180.
[32]	和媛媛, 巩在武. 考虑协同网络信息的非常规突发事件应急多指标决策模型[J]. 统计与决策, 2015 (23):75-77.
	HE Yuanyuan, GONG Zaiwu. Emergency multi-criteria decision-making model for unconventional emergencies considering collaborative network information[J]. Statistics and Decision, 2015 (23): 75-77.
[33]	陈兴, 王勇, 吴凌云, 等. 多阶段多目标多部门应急决策模型[J]. 系统工程理论与实践, 2010, 30(11):1977-1985. doi: 10.12011/1000-6788(2010)11-1977
	CHEN Xing, WANG Yong, WU Lingyun, et al. Emergency decision model with multiple stages, multiple objectives, and multidivisional cooperation[J]. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice, 2010, 30(11): 1977-1985.
[34]	范一大, 王磊, 李素菊. 重大自然灾害空间信息协同服务机制研究[J]. 遥感学报, 2011, 15(5):1053-1064.
	FAN Yida, WANG Lei, LI Suju. A study on the construction of a spatial information cooperative service mechanism for emergency disaster applications[J]. Journal of Remote Sensing, 2011, 15(5): 1053-1064.
[35]	辛禾, 王齐龙, 何璞玉, 等. 基于神经网络模型的电网企业应急协同管控机制研究[J]. 陕西电力, 2015, 43(8):1-5, 21.
	XIN He, WANG Qilong, HE Puyu, et al. Study on collaborative mechanism of grid enterprise emergency management based on neural network model[J]. Shaanxi Electric Power, 2015, 43(8): 1-5, 21.
[36]	李安楠, 邓修权, 赵秋红. 分形视角下的非常规突发事件应急协同组织[J]. 系统工程理论与实践, 2017, 37(4):937-948. doi: 10.12011/1000-6788(2017)04-0937-12
	LI Annan, DENG Xiuquan, ZHAO Qiuhong. Unconventional emergency coordinated organization based on fractal[J]. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice, 2017, 37(4): 937-948.
[37]	李秋霞. 城市突发公共卫生事件经济影响与应急处置机制研究[D]. 北京: 中国社会科学院大学, 2021.
	LI Qiuxia. Research on economic impact and emergency response mechanism of urban public health emergencies[D]. Beijing: University of Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, 2021.
[38]	高点, 史卢少博, 李婷, 等. 基于SFIC模型的医院突发公共卫生事件多主体协同应对路径研究[J]. 中国医院, 2024, 28(1):23-27.
	GAO Dian, SHI Lushaobo, LI Ting, et al. Research on multi-agent collaborative response path of hospital public health emergencies based on SFIC model[J]. China Hospitals, 2024, 28(1): 23-27.
[39]	潘潇, 樊博. 应急管理中跨部门协同能力的影响因素研究:以食品药品安全联合监管为实证背景[J]. 软科学, 2014, 28(2):52-55,60.
	PAN Xiao, FAN Bo. Research on cross-agency collaboration in the process of emergency management:employing collaborative supervision on food and medicine as background[J]. Soft Science, 2014, 28(2): 52-55,60.
[40]	欧阳艳敏. 重大突发公共卫生事件风险预警和控制模型研究[D]. 北京: 北京邮电大学, 2023.
	OUYANG Yanmin. Research on risk-early warning and control models of large-scale public health emergencies[D]. Beijing: Beijing University of Posts and Telecommunications, 2023.
[41]	刘明, 开吉, 曹杰. 重大突发公共卫生事件防控策略计算实验分析[J]. 系统工程理论与实践, 2024, 44(6):1950-1964. doi: 10.12011/SETP2023-1459
	LIU Ming, KAI Ji, CAO Jie. Computational experiment analysis of prevention and control strategies for major public health emergencies[J]. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice, 2024, 44(6): 1950-1964.
[42]	霍良安, 苏子雯. 突发公共卫生事件中应急医疗物资分配策略研究[J]. 物流科技, 2024, 47(11):1-7.
	HUO Liang'an, SU Ziwen. Research on the distribution strategy of emergency medical supplies under public health emergencies[J]. Logistics Sci-Tech, 2024, 47(11): 1-7.
[43]	朱华桂, 刘晗. 突发重大公共卫生事件社区与居民演化博弈应急策略研究[J]. 中国应急管理科学, 2024(7):100-117.
	ZHU Huagui, LIU Han. Research on emergency strategy of evolutionary game between community and residents in sudden major public health incidents[J]. China Journal of Emergency Management Science, 2024(7): 100-117.
[44]	徐明, 钟德寿, 盖赟. 重大疫情防控中政府与公众演化博弈策略分析[J]. 中国社会科学院大学学报, 2022, 42(1):126-141,146.
	XU Ming, ZHONG Deshou, GE Yun. An analysis on the evolutionary game strategies of government and the public in the prevention and control of major pandemic[J]. Journal of University of Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, 2022, 42(1): 126-141, 146.
[45]	梁雁茹, 刘亦晴. COVID-19疫情下医疗防护用品市场监管演化博弈与稳定性分析[J]. 中国管理科学, 2022, 30(10):85-95.
	LIANG Yanru, LIU Yiqing. The evolutionary game stability of the regulatory mechanism of medical protective equipment market under COVID-19 epidemic[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2022, 30(10): 85-95.
[46]	胡欢, 郭晓剑, 梁雁茹. 基于前景理论的重大疫情网络谣言管控三方演化博弈分析[J]. 情报科学, 2021, 39(7):45-53.
	HU Huan, GUO Xiaojian, LIANG Yanru. Game analysis of the three-way evolution of network rumor control under the major epidemic based on prospect theory[J]. Information Science, 2021, 39(7): 45-53.
[47]	XU Ziqi, CHENG Yukun, YAO Shuailiang. Tripartite evolutionary game model for public health emergencies[J]. Discrete Dynamics in Nature and Society, 2021, 2021:DOI:10.1155/2021/6693035.
[48]	YUAN Youwei, DU Lanying, LUO Lanjun, et al. Allocation strategy of medical supplies during a public health emergency: a tripartite evolutionary game perspective[J]. Scientific Reports, 2023, 13(1): DOI:10.1038/s41598-023-36745-6.