Improved fuzzy Borda method based evaluation of expressway safety facilities

doi:10.16265/j.cnki.issn1003-3033.2018.07.027

Abstract

Abstract: In order to provide decision-making reference for rational allocation of expressway safety facilities,an evaluation system of expressway safety facilities consisting of 15 indicators was established.An improved Borda combination evaluation method considering optimal solution and worst solution was worked out,the operational steps and numerical calculation methods of the method were given.5 expressways in Sichuan province were selected as samples,the technique for order preference by similarity to an ideal solution method and entropy value method,efficacy coefficient method,fuzzy synthetic evaluation and improved fuzzy Borda combined evaluation method were used to evaluate and compare the samples.The results show that Spearman rank correlation coefficients between the fuzzy Borda combination evaluation method and the four single evaluation methods are equal to or greater than 0.9,and the compatibility degree of the combination evaluation method is 0.98.It shows that the use of this method is highly credible.

Key words: transportation, expressway, safety facilities, fuzzy Borda, combination evaluation

CLC Number:

X913.4

XUE Feng, ZHAO Lei. Improved fuzzy Borda method based evaluation of expressway safety facilities[J]. China Safety Science Journal, 2018, 28(7): 165-171.

References

[1] 李富勇.高速公路交通安全设施系统评价研究[D].西安:长安大学,2006.
LI Fuyong.Study on evaluation of traffic safety facilities system[D].Xi'an:Chang'an University,2006.
[2] 王建军,刘乙橙,吴宜淞.高速公路交通安全设施系统评价指标及评价方法研究[J].交通运输系统工程与信息,2007,7(4):66-70.
WANG Jianjun,LIU Yicheng,WU Yisong,Evaluation of traffic safety facilities of expressway[J].Journal of Transportation Systems Engineering and Information Technology,2007,7(4):66-70.
[3] 高贺,周会聪.基于灰色逼近理想点高速公路安全设施评价[J].森林工程,2014,30(6):124-128.
GAO He,ZHOU Huicong.Evaluation of highway safety facilities based on the gray close to ideal point[J].Forest Engineering,2014,30(6):124-128.
[4] 吴瑶,陆建,郭延永.基于集对分析的高速公路交通安全设施评价[J].武汉理工大学学报,2014,36(11):71-76.
WU Yao,LU Jian,GUO Yanyong.Freeway traffic safety facilities evaluation based on set pair analysis[J].Journal of Wuhan University of Technology,2014,36 (11):71-76.
[5] 韩飞.高速公路交通安全设施优化、评价及管理系统[D].西安:长安大学,2013.
HAN Fei.Highway traffic safety facilities optimization,evaluation and management system[D].Xi'an:Chang'an University,2013.
[6] HAMMOND J L,WEGMANN F J.Daytime effects of raised pavement markers on horizontal curves[J].ITE Journal,2001,71(8):38-41.
[7] MOK J H,LANDPHAIR H C,NADERI J R.Landscape improvement impacts on roadside safety in texas[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,2006,78(3):263-274.
[8] 刘乙橙.高速公路交通安全设施系统设计与应用研究[D].西安:长安大学,2008.
LIU Yicheng.Design and application of highway traffic safety facility system[D].Xi'an:Chang'an University,2008.
[9] JTG B01—2014,公路工程技术标准[S].
JTG B01-2014,Technical standard of highway engieering[S].
[10] JTJ074—1994,高速公路交通安全设施设计及施工技术规范[S].
JTJ074-1994,Specification design and construction of expressway safety appurtenances[S].
[11] GE Minli,SUN Lu,PAN Yiyong,et al.Design and implementation of freeway infrastructure safety and emergency management system[J].Procedia -Social and Behavioral Sciences,2013,96:728-740.
[12] 苏为华,陈骥.模糊Borda法的缺陷分析及其改进思路[J].统计研究,2007,24(7):58-64.
SU Weihua,CHEN Ji.The defects of fuzzy Borda method and it's improvement[J].Statistics Research,2007,24 (7):58-64.
[13] 郭秀英,金莉.多指标决策的灰关联逼近理想点法[J].科技与管理,2010,12(5):48-51.
GUO Xiuying,JIN Li.Grey incidence TOPSIS for multiple attribute decision making[J].Science-Technology and Management,2010,12(5):48-51.
[14] 庙成,丁明涛.震区社会易损性对比分析:以芦山与鲁甸地震为例[J].中国安全科学学报,2017,27(4):169-174.
MIAO Cheng,DING Mingtao.Comparative analysis of social vulnerability of seismic areas:a case study of Lushan earthquake and Ludian earthquake[J].China Safety Science Journal,2017,27(4):169-174.
[15] 王迎超,尚岳全,孙红月,等.基于功效系数法的岩爆烈度分级预测研究[J].岩土力学,2010,31(2):529-534.
WANG Yingchao,SHANG Yuequan,SUN Hongyue,et al.Study of prediction of rock burst intensity based on efficacy coefficient method[J].Rock and Soil Mechanics,2010,31 (2):529-534.
[16] 杨浩,张国珍,杨晓妮,等.基于模糊综合评判法的洮河水环境质量评价[J].环境科学与技术,2016,39(增1):380-386.
YANG Hao,ZHANG Guozhen,YANG Xiaoni,et al.Comprehensive evaluation on water environment quality of the Tao river based on fuzzy comprehensive method[J].Environmental Science and Technology,2016,39(S1):380-386.
[17] 孙华丽,周冰雁,薛耀锋.基于“弓弦箭”模型的公共安全风险测度组合评价[J].中国安全科学学报,2013,23(7):133-138.
SUN Huali,ZHOU Bingyan,XUE Yaofeng.Integrated evaluation of public security risk measurement based on bow-string-arrow model[J].China Safety Science Journal,2013,23(7):133-138.
[18] 刘小艳,刘欣宇,王梅.隶属函数的确定及应用[J].电脑知识与技术,2010,6(31):8 831-8 832.
LIU Xiaoyan,LIU Xinyu,WANG Mei.The determination of membership function and use[J].Computer Knowledge and Technology,2010,6 (31):8 831-8 832.